All the 13th points below are academic corrections made calmly and with wisdom by Malam AbdulRahman Musa Isma'il (AMI) to Malam Jamilu, who is the Imam at the Mosque of the late Dr. Idris Abdul'aziz Dutsen-Tanshi, regarding his recent lesson.
_"Give a notice to correct you and you will accept it. Every Wednesday from 10 to 11pm. But it’s possible that someone didn’t listen at that time. That’s why I asked for your number, but then we found out you didn’t pick up. Since last night until today you still haven’t picked up!_ 🤔
_So I saw that the best way to inform you is this. But if you had picked up the call, there would be no need to send you this_ 😎"
1. Your statement: "SAHEEHUL JAMIE" is the name Al-Imam Al-Bukhari gave his book* ❌
Because Bukhari’s book is actually named: _Al-Jami' Al-Musnad As-Sahih Al-Mukhtasar Min Umoor Rasulillah (SAW) wa Sunanihi wa Ayyamih_ ✅
2. MUSLIM IS THE SAME ❌
_Al-Jami' Al-Musnad As-Sahih Min As-Sunan Binaqlil-'Adl 'Anil-'Adl 'An Rasulillah (SAW)_
That is the full name of SAHEEHU MUSLIM ✅
3. Your statement: "Any book called Sunan: Means a book that didn’t limit itself to only Sahih hadiths" ❌
In short, it means: A book that was compiled based on (Ahadith Al-Ahkam) - A book that contains hadiths of legal rulings ✅
4. Your statement: "MUSNAD is a book that was compiled not according to topics" ❌
What is meant by MUSNAD is: _A book that was compiled by gathering the hadiths of each Companion in one place, before moving to another Companion_ ✅
“(Makiyyina Aw Madaniyyina) is a separate issue on its own.”
5. AL-MUSANNAF - You tried, but what you should have said is: _It was arranged by bringing Sahih hadiths and Athar, or not. But it doesn’t do Tarjih of issues. You are the one who will try to do the Tarjih yourself while paying attention to the Fiqh of the chapter_ ✅
BENEFIT:
_Having a book that is Tahqiq-ed does not mean you should just relax and rely on everything that is graded Sahih in it. No. The benefit of a book with Tahqiq and Takhrij is simply to make it easy for you to get to the Shawahid and to the reference sources. Pay close attention_ 🥰
6. Your statement: "SAYYIDUL HUFFAZ means the leader of every single Hafiz" ❌
What happens is that scholars are given such titles to highlight their level of knowledge, but it only refers to the scholars of their own era ✅
BENEFIT:
_That’s why you’ll see Adh-Dhahabi (R.H.) say about a person: “Khatimatul Huffaz” - but he doesn’t mean no one else will ever come after. Pay close attention_ 🥰
7. Your statement: MUTTAHIM ❌
What you should say is: MUTTAHAM ✅
8. Your statement: "FATHUL MUGHEETH is by Al-Iraqi" ❌
_Alfiyyah is by Al-Iraqi, but FATHUL MUGHEETH is by As-Sakhawi_ ✅
9. Your statement: "A'lamuhum IBNUL MADEENI means the one who knew the chain of hadith the most" ❌
*What is meant is: The one who knew the ‘Ilal of Hadith the most* ✅
10. Your statement: "WADA'AN LIKITABIN means the one who is best at writing a book" ❌
What is meant is: The one who is best at narrating from memory as if he were reading from a book ✅
11. Your statement: "KITABUD DAHARA is how it is in MUSNAD" ❌
_The book MUSNAD doesn’t have chapters. It just pours out the hadiths. But I suspect this was a slip of the tongue_ 😎
12. *MYour statement: KAM YAMSAHU ALAL KHUFFAINI ❌
KAM YUMSAHU ALAL KHUFFAINI✅
13. Your statement: SIRU A'ALAMIN NUBALA ❌
*SIYARU A'ALAMIN NUBALA* ✅
That’s a few of the points I’ll comment on for you.
_I have nothing to do with correcting Arabic grammar. This is only the part related to Hadith that needed to be corrected for you. If Allah wills that you correct it, then there will be no need for me to keep correcting you on social media_ 😏
STUDY BEFORE ANYTHING ELSE
~AMI
